Skip to main content

Category

Protein shakes: nutrition facts compared

Compare ready-to-drink shakes by the nutrition on each bottle. Ingredients and storage · Chocolate comparison

Food results

Matching foods available.

How this list is selected

Includes all protein shakes. Results are sorted by protein (high to low). Items missing the value used for sorting are left out rather than treated as zero.

Show full nutrition table
Foods with per-serving nutrition facts, as given by each nutrition source.
ItemBrandCategoryCaloriesProteinFiberSodiumLast checked
OWYN Dark Chocolate Protein Shake package
Dark Chocolate Protein ShakeServing: 12 fl oz (355 ml)Protein / 100 cal: 11.1 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
OWYNProtein shakes18020 g3 g350 mgSeptember 8, 2026
OWYN Smooth Vanilla Protein Shake package
Smooth Vanilla Protein ShakeServing: 1 shake (355 ml)Protein / 100 cal: 11.1 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
OWYNProtein shakes18020 g3 g270 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Cacao Bean Protein Shake package
Cacao Bean Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g240 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Chocolate Banana Protein Shake package
Chocolate Banana Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g6 g280 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Shake package
Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g420 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Cinnamon Horchata Protein Shake package
Cinnamon Horchata Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g240 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Coconut Almond Protein Shake package
Coconut Almond Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g240 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Cold Brew Coffee Protein Shake package
Cold Brew Coffee Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g240 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Koia Dubai Chocolate Protein Shake package
Dubai Chocolate Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g220 mgSeptember 21, 2026
Koia Vanilla Bean Protein Shake package
Vanilla Bean Protein ShakeServing: 1 bottle (12 fl oz)Protein / 100 cal: 9.5 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
KoiaProtein shakes19018 g7 g240 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Orgain Vegan Organic Nutrition Shake Vanilla Bean package
Vegan Organic Nutrition Shake Vanilla BeanServing: 1 carton (330 ml)Protein / 100 cal: 7 g
VeganGluten free
Add to compare
OrgainProtein shakes23016 g2 g260 mgSeptember 8, 2026
Atkins Milk Chocolate Delight Meal Shake package
Milk Chocolate Delight Meal ShakeServing: 1 shake (325 ml)Protein / 100 cal: 9.4 g
Add to compare
AtkinsProtein shakes16015 g3 g250 mgSeptember 14, 2026
How is this calculated?
This shows how much protein or fiber a food provides per 100 calories. See Methodology for the calculation.
What does “Not provided” mean?
The source does not list a verified exact value. “<1 g” means the label lists less than 1 gram; it is not treated as zero or used in calculated ratios.
Understanding the nutrition data

Nutrition information for comparison. Not medical advice.

Choose a protein shake: milk, plants and storage

Start with ingredients and storage, then compare the whole container. Lactose-free is not milk-free: Nutrition Plan still contains milk. Plant-based is not nut-free: vegan Koia Cacao Bean declares tree nuts. OWYN’s dairy-free and allergen-testing statements are manufacturer claims, not a promise of allergy safety. For allergy questions, check the exact label and current manufacturer information.

Three exact US shakes, per whole labeled container
Check before buyingFairlife Nutrition Plan ChocolateOWYN Smooth Vanilla Pro Elite bottleKoia Cacao Bean Protein bottle
Whole labeled serving1 bottle, 340 mL (11.5 fl oz)1 shake, 355 mL; 1 serving per bottle1 bottle, 12 fl oz; 1 serving per bottle
Protein30 g32 g18 g
Calories150200190
Fiber1 g3 g7 g
Total sugars2 g0 g4 g
Added sugars0 g0 g4 g
Selected ingredients and sweetenersFiltered lowfat milk, lactase; sucralose, acesulfame potassium, stevia and monkfruit.Pea and organic pumpkin seed protein, flaxseed oil blend; monkfruit and stevia.Almond milk, brown rice, pea and chickpea protein; agave and chicory fiber, cane sugar and monkfruit.
Manufacturer claims and allergen wordingManufacturer: lactose-free. Contains milk.Manufacturer: plant-based, vegan and dairy-free; tests and validates for the top nine allergens. Check the exact label and current manufacturer information.Manufacturer: vegan. Contains statement: Tree Nuts (Almonds, Coconuts).
Storage: unopenedShelf-stable; keep in a cool, dry place.Refrigeration not required.Perishable; keep refrigerated.
Storage: after openingRefrigerate the unused portion.Refrigerate after opening.Keep refrigerated.

Sugar and sweeteners answer different questions

Nutrition Plan has 2 g total sugar and 0 g added sugar. Koia has 4 g of each. OWYN lists zero for both, but includes monkfruit and stevia. Zero added sugar does not mean no sweeteners.

Does it need a fridge before opening?

Koia Protein needs refrigeration even unopened. Unopened Nutrition Plan and OWYN do not; refrigerate after opening. Follow the exact container’s storage and expiry instructions. These Koia instructions do not describe Nutrition cartons, Elite or powders.

Choose, check, then compare

  1. Match the line, flavor and size. This OWYN is the 32 g Pro Elite 355 mL bottle, not the 330 mL Tetra carton or regular 20 g line. These examples exclude other flavors.
  2. Check claims, ingredients and storage. The directory’s vegan filter uses evidenced claims; it is not an allergen filter. See the methodology.
  3. Use the category filters and sort above, then compare whole-container manufacturer figures. Read the Koia Cacao Bean guide, OWYN Pro Elite guide or Nutrition Plan vs Premier comparison. For other milk-based chocolate lines, see the existing chocolate comparison below.

These three labels and storage instructions checked November 16, 2026. Catalog check dates remain separate. Sources: product panels linked above; Nutrition Plan FAQ, OWYN ready-to-drink FAQ and Koia Protein product FAQ.

Core Power Elite vs Premier Protein: classic and Ultimate

Which Premier line matters: classic Chocolate has 30 g protein in an 11.5 fl oz shake. Ultimate Chocolate has 42 g in a 14 fl oz shake. Core Power Elite Chocolate also has 42 g in a 14 fl oz bottle. Compare the exact containers before choosing.

Manufacturer labels checked October 4, 2026. This comparison excludes regular 26 g Core Power, other flavors and powders. Check your actual package.

Nutrition per whole container, from the three manufacturer labels
Per whole containerCore Power Elite ChocolatePremier classic ChocolatePremier Ultimate Chocolate
Serving (one container)14 fl oz / 414 ml11.5 fl oz14 fl oz
Calories230160220
Protein42 g30 g42 g
Protein per 100 calories (calculated)18.3 g18.8 g19.1 g
Fiber2 g2 g2 g
Sodium260 mg230 mg290 mg
Total sugars7 g1 g2 g
Added sugars0 g0 g0 g
Saturated fat2 g1 g1 g
Declared allergensMilkMilk and soyMilk and soy

Sources: Core Power Elite Chocolate; Premier classic Chocolate (11.5 fl oz label); Premier Ultimate Chocolate.

What changes when you compare the bottles fairly?

Whole-container protein: the two 42 g shakes tie. Each provides 12 g more protein than classic Premier in a larger container. That does not establish how much you personally need.

Protein relative to calories: protein ÷ calories × 100 gives 18.3, 18.8 and 19.1 g, rounded to one decimal place. These are close figures; protein density is one comparison axis, not an overall health score.

Between the two 14 fl oz shakes: Ultimate has 10 fewer calories and 30 mg more sodium than Core Power Elite. It also has less total sugar and saturated fat. Matching protein amounts do not mean identical nutrition.

Allergens and sugar: all three declare milk; both Premier labels also declare soy. All three show zero added sugar, but total sugars differ. No added sugar does not mean sugar-free.

What we have not tested

This is a label comparison. We have not tested flavor, texture or individual tolerance. It cannot predict which drink will suit someone taking GLP-1 medication, and it is not a meal-replacement plan. Both linked Premier source pages say to use the product as a food supplement only and not for weight reduction.

Use the directory above to compare other shakes. Our methodology explains the calculated ratios.

Related lists